2 reports and 2 rounds. Came back with a reject, but reports were at least somewhat useful. No flyouts yet. The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization. Super fast and clear feedback. Economics Job Market. PhD & Postdoctoral Research Fellow Job Market Candidates 2022 - 2023 Home Page CV ANDREW HANNON PHD Research Fields: Macroeconomics, Household Finance, Sovereign Debt, Financial Stability and the Housing Market Job Market Paper: Falling Behind: Delinquency and Foreclosure in a Housing Crisis References: Dr. . Other was very thorough and generally favourable. Bad experience overall. Manuscript was withdrawn - editor had assigned referees within 3 months of submission but then these were apparently not forthcoming. RR with major changes, then RR with minor changes, then accepted after 1 week. Fast process and 2 helpful ref. Comments from Larry very helpful. 51 of 55 African countries snub Ukraine Economics Job Market Rumors They ignored all my emails and I had to pull out after more than a year. Ridicolous report: 3 lines where the referee asked to address "geopolitical" issues. Desk reject within two weeks. After fully addressing the reviewers' comments at each round, the article got rejected in the third round with a totally "ex nihilo" issue risen by one of the reviewers, who never mentioned the issue before. Had to beg to get a useless ref report. This is a wiki for tracking searches in various categories for academic (i.e. Hastily written by PhD student. Title: Researcher Location: COLOMBIA JEL Classifications:. Unhappy with the outcome of course, but pleased with the process and the handling. 9 month for two reports. The AE's letter was useful, although no suggestion what to try next. The editor handling the paper had no idea about the literature. Initial response slow, then extremely quick after R&R. paper.? They were polite in point out a crucial mistake at the beginning of the paper were a new theoretical model was presented. Very efficiently run journal (at least my experience). Both referees really spent time on the paper and gave lots of suggestions.So did the editor. Desk reject in 10 days with useless AE comments completely unrelated to the paper.

Creating Policies To Facilitate Inmate Readjustment To Society Upon Release, Articles E